Wednesday, August 1, 2012

Romney's Jewish Culture Gaffe?

Remarking on Israel's double per capita GDP compared to the West Bank, Romney said: "as I come here and I look out over this city and consider the accomplishments of the people of this nation, I recognize the power of at least culture and a few other things,"

The Palestinians were quick to react, claiming the comments were racist. In American politics, any such reaction defines the statement as a gaffe.

The Palestinians have a point. We can't expect them to succeed economically when they are under occupation. Their daily commutes are stifled by walls and hours long waits at checkpoints. Their tax revenues and exports are controlled by Israel and cut off for long periods due to the behavior of militants who are not under the control of the people.

On the other hand, why has this conflict dragged on so long? In my opinion, it is solely a result of culture. Not the Jewish culture, but the arab culture. In that culture, one must never admit defeat. Instead, one carries a grudge and vows revenge across generations and even centuries.

Human history may be seen as an uneasy balance between barbarism and civilization. During barbarous times, a culture of revenge is useful. Strength and the appearance of strength are all important. But during civilized times, it is advantageous to submit to greater military strength and appeal instead to the sympathies of the stronger society. This is the power of Gandhi, Martin Luther King, and Jesus.

Romney's comments are indeed a gaffe, as the POTUS needs to speak carefully, but they are correct. What the Palestinians, and indeed the arabs, need is a leader to preach the power of submission in a civilized world.